ITAT : Pre-existing commercial property can't be treated as residential; Allows exemption u/s 54F
Mr. I.Ifthiqar Ashiq
June 20 2013
Commercial building cannot be treated as ‘residential house property’ merely because rental income chargeable u/s 22 as 'Income from house property'; Income Tax Act does not make any ...View more

ITAT : Lambasts CA for professional misconduct; rejects recall application in "personal" capacity 
Omkar Nagreeya Sahkari Bank Ltd.
June 19 2013
ITAT's Single Member bench expresses grave displeasure on professional misconduct of Chartered Accountant; Dismisses application filed by CA in his "personal capacity" for recalling order sheet withou...View more

ITAT : Retrospective explanation limiting Sec 80-IA(4) deduction should 'stand down', Follows SC ruling 
ARSS Infrastructure Projects Ltd.
June 19 2013
Rejects Revenue’s contention that legislative intent of amending explanation to 80IA was to provide benefit only to Build, Operate and Transfer contracts (BOT); Explanation to Sec 80IA to exclud...View more

ITAT : Adjournment only for sufficient cause, not at 'leisure or pleasure' of parties 
Rushabh Vatika
June 19 2013
Denies adjournment since application did not show "sufficient cause" and assessee had more than a month's notice to prepare for hearing; Adjournments can't be sought at leisure or pleasure; Without va...View more

ITAT : Tax audit filing mandatory though e-filed return delayed; Confirms penalty 
Himalyan Labour & Construction Coop Society Ltd
June 17 2013
Furnishing of tax audit report u/s 44AB independent of filing of tax return; Exclusion of enclosing tax audit report alongwith e-filed tax return not applicable, for delayed tax return; Confirms levy ...View more

Read All

Securitisation trust a 'smokescreen', confirms Appellate Commissioner

May 29 2013
CIT (A) rejects status of Securitisation SPV as 'trust' under IT Act; Trust set-up a farce, in reality represents an "Association of Persons" comprising of bank, settler, trust and mutual funds; Rejec...View more

ITAT SB to decide vexed issue of 'PMS income' classification

May 28 2013
ITAT Special Bench to determine if income from "Portfolio Management Scheme" constitutes 'Business income' or 'Capital Gains';  Special Bench set up due to contradictory ITAT ruling...View more

Revenue focuses on DTAA interpretation, transaction documents, McDowell/Voda in Sanofi SLP

May 27 2013
Revenue's SLP against AP HC ruling in Sanofi raises issue of whether foreign JV holding company can be considered a company with business substance or be ignored being a puppet subsidiary; A...View more

ITAT SB reserves ruling on Linklaters-Set Satellite, IHI-retro amendment conflict

April 23 2013
ITAT Special Bench concludes hearings in Clifford Chance LLP's case to decide taxability of foreign partnership firms in India; SB to decide on applicability of SC ruling in Ishikawajima in ...View more

Analysing Revenue's Rs. 2000cr tax case on Nokia

April 15 2013
After a survey carried out on Nokia India’s facilities in Jan 2013, IT Dept has slapped a Rs 2000 Cr+ tax demand for TDS default on software related payments made to Nokia Finland for 6 Financia...View more

Read All
HC : Retro amendment route to "cure defect" constitutionally valid, but penalty levy "arbitrary" 
Jindal Poly Films Ltd. & Anr
June 10 2013
HC upholds constitutional validity of retrospective amendment to Sec 93 of Maharashtra Value Added Tax Act providing proportionate incentives to eligible units; Legislation of validation clause "const...View more

ITAT : Advt expenses by licensed-manufacturer deductible; Concurrent benefit to brand owner irrelevant 
Khambhatta Family Trust
June 10 2013
Allows deduction for advertisement expenditure incurred on products using brand 'Rasna"; Brand was owned by another entity and manufacturing was carried out based on usage rights; Advertisement expend...View more

HC : Upholds loss on shares held as stock by Bank; RBI guidelines irrelevant 
The Karnataka Bank Ltd.
June 10 2013
Loss on valuation for shares held as stock in trade (based on lower of cost or market value) for tax purposes upheld; Shares held as investments in balance sheet as per RBI Guidelines but treated as s...View more

ITAT : Disallows legal fees to defend directors in Narcotics case; Invokes Sec 37(1) explanation 
OPM International Pvt. Ltd.
June 10 2013
Disallows professional fees paid by assessee company to defend its Directors involved in a Narcotics case; Explanation to Sec 37(1) clearly provides that no deduction allowable for any expenditure inc...View more

ITAT : Beneficial not legal ownership of asset relevant to claim depreciation 
Dhimant Mehta Computing Solutions Private Limited
June 07 2013
Beneficial ownership of asset sufficient to claim depreciation if asset being used for the purpose of business; Rejects Revenue's contention that legal ownership of motor car with Company ne...View more

Read All

Commodities Transaction Tax to apply from July 1, Govt announces CTT rules

June 20 2013
Commodities Transaction Tax to be effective from July 1, 2013; CBDT notifies the Commodities Transaction Tax Rules, 2013 to be effective from July 1, 2013; Notifies 23 agricultural commoditi...View more

G8 nations call for automatic info exchange, country by country tax reporting

June 19 2013
On 18th June 2013, at the end of G8 Summit, attended by heads of the wealthiest countries, a G8 Lough Erne Declaration was issued, calling for fair taxes, increased transparency, open trade and good g...View more

G8 receives report from OECD on "A Step Change in Tax Transparency"

June 18 2013
OECD presents report on "A Step Change in Tax Transparency" to G8 countries; Report sets out key success factors for an effective model for automatic exchange, outlines four concrete steps needed to p...View more

New CBDT Chairperson's letter stresses "non-intrusive" regime, warns "non-filers"

June 17 2013
New CBDT Chairperson, Dr. Sudha Sharma, addresses tax department officers on elevation; Acknowledges FM's guiding principles of non-intrusive and non-adversarial tax administration; Terms base of 3.5 ...View more

CBDT transfers give International tax wing a new look

June 17 2013
The transfer orders of over 360 CITs announced by CBDT on Friday, June 14 has affected International tax wing of Income tax department the most. Almost 2/3 of the 15 DITs have been transferred out of ...View more

Read All
CBDT announces major reshuffle; Transfers over 360 CITs/DITs
June 14 2013
CBDT announces transfer of 367 CITs and DITs; 246 transfers within city whereas 121 inter-city transfers ordered with immediate effect ...View more

HC : Permits 'Loophole' exploitation; share sale effecting immovable property transfer, legitimate tax planning 
Bhoruka Engineering Inds. Ltd.
June 13 2013
Long term capital gains exemption u/s 10(38) allowed on sale of shares in a group company that had effect of transferring underlying land; Land was acquired into a listed company and immediate share t...View more

CBDT transfers give International tax wing a new look
June 17 2013
The transfer orders of over 360 CITs announced by CBDT on Friday, June 14 has affected International tax wing of Income tax department the most. Almost 2/3 of the 15 DITs have been transferred out of ...View more

ITAT : Distinguishes Chaturbhuj Kapadia ruling; Development agreement not transfer u/s 2(47) 
S. Ranjith Reddy
June 13 2013
Not every development agreement satisfies conditions of Sec. 53A of Transfer of Property Act (TP Act) to constitute transfer u/s 2(47); Rejects Revenue's reliance on Bombay HC ruling in Chaturbhuj Kap...View more

ITAT : Adjournment only for sufficient cause, not at 'leisure or pleasure' of parties 
Rushabh Vatika
June 19 2013
Denies adjournment since application did not show "sufficient cause" and assessee had more than a month's notice to prepare for hearing; Adjournments can't be sought at leisure or pleasure; Without va...View more