ITAT : Follows CGG Veritas ruling, Sec 44BB benefit on exploration services available pre 2011
Schlumberger Asia Services Limited
May 19 2012
Pre-2011, income from wire line logging, perforation and other services eligible for concessional rate of taxation u/s 44BB even if PE exists in India; Service income not taxable on gross basis at hig...View more

AAR : R&D cost allocation taxable as royalty, allocation key has no meaning, rules AAR
"A” Systems
May 19 2012
Cost allocation of common Research & Development expenses received by German Group company from Indian affiliate taxable as royalty; Allocation key has no meaning as only group companies usin...View more

HC : Interest on advance tax default not automatic , SC ruling in Anjum Ghaswala inapplicable
Sarin Chemical Laboratory
May 18 2012
Interest on advance tax default (u/s 234A, 234B and 234C) not leviable unless specifically mentioned in the assessment order; HC reconciles SC rulings in Anjum M.H Ghaswala and Ran...View more

ITAT : Development agreement assigning absolute rights in land taxable as capital gains even without final conveyance
Late Shri Ramesh F. Singhal
May 18 2012
Transfer of land under development agreement triggering capital gains takes place in year in which possession granted and development rights assigned and not upon final conveyance; Receipt of balance ...View more

HC : 'Inland Container Depots' located away from sea ports, qualify as ‘inland port’, 80IA deduction available
Container Corporation of India Ltd
May 17 2012
Container Corporation of India entitled to deduction u/s 80IA on income from Inland Container Depots; ICDs are ‘inland ports’ and covered under definition of term ‘infrastructure fac...View more

Read All

Guj HC reserves judgement in writ challenging constitutional validity of DEPB amendment u/s 80HHC

May 11 2012
The Supreme Court had bunched together all cases filed in various courts on this issue and sent it back to Gujarat HC a few months back. Advocate Saurabh Soparkar argued on behalf of the petitioners a...View more

Constitutional validity of MAT and DDT levy on SEZ challenged before Bombay HC

April 20 2012
Association of EOUs and SEZs (the Association) has filed a writ petition before Bombay High Court challenging the the constitutional validity of the amendments to Sec. 115JB and 115O introduced by Fin...View more

AAR not fact finding authority, should decline applications where facts disputed, argues Salve

April 16 2012
In arguments that may have far reaching implications on the scope, functioning and powers of the Authority for Advance Ruling, Senior Advocate Harish Salve strongly argued earlier today, that the AAR ...View more

Rolls Royce files review petition in Delhi HC on PE ruling

March 26 2012
Petition seeks review of HC's conclusion on existence of business connection, PE in India for Rolls Royce Singapore and on determination by AO of arm's length 'profit' as against 'price'  Rolls ...View more

SC to hear maintainability of SLPs against AAR decisions on April 16th

March 05 2012
AAR rulings are supposed to be binding but of late almost every other AAR decision is being appealed against by both the applicant as well as Revenue. Probably this has prompted the apex court to...View more

Read All
HC : Preparing engineering drawings & designs amounts to 'manufacture', deduction u/s 80IA available 
John Brown Technologies
May 15 2012
Preparing engineering drawings, design and other technical know-how amounts to ‘manufacture’ for claiming deduction u/s 80IA; Assessee brought into existence a new and distinct article/obj...View more

ITAT : Set-off brought forward speculative loss before normal losses of current year
Shri Ashok Mittal
May 15 2012
Investment management and advisory fees received from Mauritius based companies by Investment Manager taxable as business income, not 'income from other sources'; Brought forward speculative losses to...View more

ITAT : Super-stockist not manager of assessee, TDS u/s 194J not applicable 
Piramal Healthcare Ltd
May 14 2012
Relation between assessee and super-stockist on ‘principal to principal’ basis and super-stockist not ‘manager’ of assessee; Super-stockist purchased goods from assessee for on...View more

HC : Sec 11 exemption available only if charitable purpose as well as application of income in India 
National Association of Software and Services Companies
May 11 2012
Payment of taxes an ‘application of income’ while computing income of trust; Income available for application to be computed as per ‘commercial principles’ and not as per stric...View more

HC : Allows Infosys' review petition, Sets aside exclusion of foreign currency expenses for Sec. 80HHE benefit
Infosys Ltd
May 11 2012
Review petition of Infosys claiming typo error in CA certificate allowed; HC sets aside its order upholding exclusion of foreign currency expenses for computation of Sec 80HHE deduction; Infosys engag...View more

Read All

FM refuses to concede an inch on retro amendments as Rajya Sabha clears Finance Bill

May 16 2012
Rajya Sabha clears Finance Bill 2012; Retro amendments done by many FMs but why hue and cry only now, questions Pranab Mukherjee; Adv Y.P. Trivedi (NCP) forcefully defends taxing Vodafone-Hutch deal, ...View more

Asia officials highlight compliance priorities at ITR's Asia Tax Forum in Singapore

May 16 2012
Past and present tax officials from Asia and the US, speaking on the first day of International Tax Review's Asia Tax Forum in Singapore, painted a picture of compliance in their jurisdictions. In som...View more

Alienation includes actual and ‘deemed disposal’, rules South African SCA

May 14 2012
The Supreme Court of Appeal in South Africa, ruling in favour of the assessee, has held that treaty benefits can be extended to capital gains arising on ‘deemed disposal’ of assets.  ...View more

HC - Payment of taxes by NASSCOM an application of income; Expenses incurred abroad is Not

May 10 2012
The ruling has been delivered in the case of National Association of Software and Services Companies (NASSCOM). Senior Counsel Ajay Vora argued for NASSCOM, while Standing Counsel Sanjeev Sabharwal a...View more

SC dismisses Revenue SLP in Nalwa Sons, no penalty on MAT despite concealment

May 10 2012
SC dismisses IT Department SLP against Delhi HC decision in Nalwa Sons Investments;No concealment penalty can be levied in case of a tax loss reduction where final tax payable under MAT provision...View more

Read All
ITAT : Tax paid abroad by Mastek allowable u/s 37, Disallowance u/s 40(a)(ii) restricted to ‘Indian’ tax
Mastek Ltd
May 15 2012
Tax paid by assessee in Belgium allowable as deduction u/s 37; Payment of such taxes not 'application of income'; Tax on profits chargeable under ‘Indian Income-tax Act’ and not foreign ta...View more

HC : Sale & lease back deal not sham, applies “look at” approach
High Energy Batteries (India) Ltd
May 15 2012
Sale & lease back of machinery not a 'sham' or 'colourable' device to avail benefit of depreciation even invoking  McDowell ruling; Payment of hire purchase instalment by lessee on behal...View more

FM refuses to concede an inch on retro amendments as Rajya Sabha clears Finance Bill
May 16 2012
Rajya Sabha clears Finance Bill 2012; Retro amendments done by many FMs but why hue and cry only now, questions Pranab Mukherjee; Adv Y.P. Trivedi (NCP) forcefully defends taxing Vodafone-Hutch deal, ...View more

ITAT : No TDS on interest reimbursement to parent co if credit facility from bank availed through it
Onward eServices Ltd
May 14 2012
Interest cost reimbursed to parent not liable to TDS u/s 194A, as such reimbursement not 'income' in hands of parent; Though credit facility was enjoyed by assessee, bank's approval for transferring s...View more

HC : Sec 48 indexation benefit available on redeemable preference shares redemption, rejects characterisation as 'debt'
Enam Securities Private Limited
May 15 2012
Indexation benefit u/s 48 available on redemption of non-cumulative redeemable preference shares; Preference shares not in the nature of ‘bonds or debentures,’ as alleged by AO, only becau...View more